DHS claims 70% of ICE arrests are of noncitizens charged or convicted of crimes

Misleading

Facts are technically correct but framed in a way that likely leads to a wrong impression. Learn more in Methodology.

Interesting: 0/0 • Support: 0/0Log in to vote

other

ICE or DHS statistics and underlying arrest datasets show that 70% of persons arrested by ICE during the referenced reporting period were charged with or convicted of a crime in the United States.

Source summary
The U.S. Department of Homeland Security on Jan. 27, 2026 announced that ICE arrested a group of noncitizens it describes as the "worst of the worst," including people the release says were convicted of murder, child cruelty, assault, battery and multiple DUI charges. The statement names five individuals and their alleged convictions and locations, and directs the public to a webpage, WOW.DHS.Gov, for more cases. The release also repeats a DHS claim that 70% of ICE arrests are of noncitizens charged or convicted of crimes in the United States.
Latest fact check

ICE and DHS have repeatedly used a 70% figure, but official ICE and independent analyses show the percentage depends on the denominator and time window. ICE’s public dashboards and independent researchers (TRAC, Deportation Data Project, PolitiFact, EconoFact, Cato) show that at point-in-time snapshots of people in ICE detention in 2025–Jan 2026 roughly half to three-quarters had no criminal conviction, while analyses of all arrestees over some multi‑month periods rise toward ~64–66% with convictions or pending charges; violent convictions are a small share. Thus the DHS statement is presented without specifying the time frame or whether it counts “arrests” versus “people detained” and so is misleading: the 70% claim can be produced using selected time windows/definitions but does not match other reasonable snapshots of ICE arrests or detention.

Timeline

  1. Update · Jan 28, 2026, 09:16 AMMisleading
    ICE and DHS have repeatedly used a 70% figure, but official ICE and independent analyses show the percentage depends on the denominator and time window. ICE’s public dashboards and independent researchers (TRAC, Deportation Data Project, PolitiFact, EconoFact, Cato) show that at point-in-time snapshots of people in ICE detention in 2025–Jan 2026 roughly half to three-quarters had no criminal conviction, while analyses of all arrestees over some multi‑month periods rise toward ~64–66% with convictions or pending charges; violent convictions are a small share. Thus the DHS statement is presented without specifying the time frame or whether it counts “arrests” versus “people detained” and so is misleading: the 70% claim can be produced using selected time windows/definitions but does not match other reasonable snapshots of ICE arrests or detention.
  2. Original article · Jan 27, 2026

Comments

Only logged-in users can comment.
Loading…