Important News

DHS/ICE says thousands of noncitizens with active detainers were released from California jails

Interesting: 0/0 • Support: 0/0Log in to vote

Key takeaways

  • ICE Acting Director Todd Lyons sent a letter to California Attorney General Rob Bonta urging California to honor ICE arrest detainers.
  • ICE reports 4,561 criminal noncitizens were released from California custody since January 20, 2026.
  • ICE reports there are 33,179 noncitizens in California jurisdictions with active ICE detainers.
  • ICE provided aggregate counts of alleged crimes for released individuals (e.g., 31 homicides, 661 assaults, 1,489 drug offenses) and for those with active detainers (e.g., 399 homicides, 8,380 drug offenses).
  • The release lists multiple named individuals and case details; some were later re-arrested by ICE and removed from the United States.
  • ICE frames the issue as a public-safety concern and calls on California officials to cooperate with federal immigration enforcement.

Follow Up Questions

What is an ICE arrest detainer and what authority does it give federal agents?Expand

An ICE arrest detainer (Form I-247/I-247A) is a written request from ICE/DHS asking a state or local law enforcement agency to notify ICE and, if possible, hold a named person up to 48 hours (excluding weekends/holidays) beyond when they would otherwise be released so ICE can assume custody. It is an administrative request—not a judicial arrest warrant—and does not itself authorize federal agents to arrest someone; ICE must rely on separate statutory authority, a judicial warrant, or its own probable-cause determinations to take custody. (Detainers are issued under 8 C.F.R. §287.7 and ICE has internal detainer policies.)

Are California local jails legally required to honor ICE detainers, and what laws or policies guide that decision?Expand

No. California law (the California Values Act, SB 54; Gov. Code §7284.6) generally prohibits state and local agencies from using resources to hold or transfer people for immigration enforcement and bars honoring ICE detainers except in narrow exceptions (e.g., a judicial warrant or judicial probable-cause determination or other statutory exceptions). California Attorney General guidance and local policies implement SB 54; detainers therefore are not legally mandatory for California jails.

How did DHS/ICE calculate the numbers of released individuals and the crime counts (time period and data sources)?Expand

ICE’s numbers in the DHS release reflect ICE administrative data counting noncitizens with active detainers and those ICE says were released from local custody since Jan. 20, 2026; the agency reported aggregate crime-category tallies for those groups. ICE did not publish a public methodology or underlying jail records in the release; standard ICE practice is to use internal enforcement databases (e.g., IDENT/ENFORCE/NCIC entries and detention records) to produce such aggregate counts. The DHS news release itself gives the counts but not a full, independent data methodology.

What is the legal difference between being arrested, charged, or convicted in the counts ICE provides?Expand

Arrest, charge, and conviction are distinct legal stages: an arrest is a seizure by police based on suspected criminal conduct; a charge (complaint, information, or indictment) is a prosecutor’s formal allegation that the person committed a crime; a conviction is a court finding (guilty plea or jury/verdict) establishing criminal guilt. ICE’s aggregate counts typically include arrests or criminal records listed in enforcement databases and may mix different stages (arrested/charged/convicted) unless ICE specifies otherwise—so the counts do not by themselves prove convictions.

What happens after ICE arrests someone who was previously released (e.g., detention, removal, prosecution)?Expand

When ICE later arrests someone it previously sought via a detainer, the person can be placed in federal immigration detention, screened for removal (deportation) proceedings, and—if removable—issued a Notice to Appear and processed for removal; ICE may detain the person pending removal or release them on bond/parole under immigration law. Criminal prosecution by state or federal authorities is separate; ICE removal actions are civil (immigration) proceedings, though ICE can coordinate with prosecutors where criminal charges exist.

Who are Todd Lyons, Rob Bonta, and Gavin Newsom and what roles do they play in immigration enforcement and state cooperation?Expand

Todd Lyons is the acting director of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and a senior DHS law‑enforcement official responsible for ICE enforcement policies; Rob Bonta is California’s attorney general, who issues state legal guidance (including on SB 54) and defends state policy on cooperation with federal immigration authorities; Gavin Newsom is California’s governor, who sets statewide policy priorities and can direct state agencies but does not control local law enforcement decisions directly. All three are key interlocutors in disputes over state‑local cooperation with federal immigration enforcement.

Comments

Only logged-in users can comment.
Loading…