Important News

DHS Says New York Proposal to Bar Local Police from Partnering with ICE Poses Public-Safety Risk

Interesting: 0/0 • Support: 0/0Log in to vote

Key takeaways

  • DHS released a statement condemning Governor Hochul’s proposal to prevent local police from partnering with ICE.
  • DHS reports that 6,947 people with ICE detainers were released in New York since January 20 and that 7,113 people remain in New York custody with active detainers.
  • DHS lists specific offense counts tied to those released: 29 homicides, 2,509 assaults, 199 burglaries, 305 robberies, 392 drug offenses, 300 weapons offenses, and 207 sexual predatory offenses.
  • DHS quoted Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin saying that limiting cooperation would reduce safety and urging Governor Hochul to hand over those individuals to ICE.
  • The release includes named case examples of individuals DHS characterizes as criminal noncitizens arrested by ICE in New York.

Follow Up Questions

What is an ICE detainer and how does it work?Expand

An ICE detainer (Form I-247/I-247A) is an administrative request from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement asking a local, state, or federal jail to: (1) notify ICE before releasing a person and/or (2) hold the person for up to 48 hours (excluding weekends/holidays) so ICE can assume custody. Detainers are not judicial warrants and are legally treated as a non‑binding request in many jurisdictions; they have been subject to legal challenges about their binding force and Fourth Amendment limits.

What does it mean in practice for local police to "partner and cooperate" with ICE?Expand

‘Partnering and cooperating’ with ICE typically means state/local agencies do one or more of: honor ICE detainers (notify and hold people for up to 48 hours), enter 287(g) MOAs to deputize officers to perform immigration functions, allow ICE to interview/screen people in jails (CAP/Secure Communities), share biometric and booking data, transfer custody to ICE, or execute ICE administrative warrants. The exact activities depend on agreements and local policies.

How were the counts (6,947 released; 7,113 with active detainers) calculated and are there independent sources to verify them?Expand

The DHS numbers (6,947 released; 7,113 with active detainers) are figures stated in the DHS press release; the release does not publish underlying datasets or methodology. Independent public verification is limited: ICE/DHS internal case-management databases are the likely source but DHS/ICE have not released a public line‑by‑line accounting for these counts, and I find no independent audit or third‑party dataset that confirms those exact totals as of the date of the release.

Can a state governor legally bar local police departments from cooperating with federal immigration enforcement?Expand

Yes. Under the Constitution and Supreme Court precedents, states and state officials generally may refuse to assist federal immigration enforcement (anti‑commandeering doctrine). A governor can direct state/local agencies and officers (to the extent they are state actors) not to honor ICE detainers or enter 287(g) agreements; federal law cannot force state or local police to perform federal duties. However, the federal government can lawfully detain and remove noncitizens and can seek cooperation via MOAs, grants, or other incentives. Legal disputes can arise over specific practices (e.g., whether local holds without warrant violate the Fourth Amendment).

Who is Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin and what is her role at DHS?Expand

Tricia McLaughlin is the Assistant Secretary for the Office of Strategy, Policy, and Plans (or a DHS Assistant Secretary level official referenced in DHS statements); in the press release she is quoted describing DHS policy and urging state cooperation. (DHS organizational pages identify Assistant Secretaries and their roles in shaping strategy and public messaging for DHS components including ICE.)

How does DHS define the term "criminal illegal alien" and what standards determine which offenses are counted?Expand

DHS/ICE use terms like “criminal illegal alien” to refer to non‑U.S. citizens who have criminal convictions or arrests in ICE/departmental records; DHS counts offenses by matching ICE detainers or custody records to the agency’s charge/conviction fields. However, standards vary (arrest vs. conviction, charging codes, differences across jurisdictions), and DHS releases typically do not describe whether counts reflect convictions, pending charges, or arrest allegations—so the precise standard for the counted offenses is not fully documented in the release.

Comments

Only logged-in users can comment.
Loading…